Airbus Feedback
Unfortunately, the team did not make it through to Round 2 of the competition. We did receive feedback from the panel as to why our idea did not proceed:
"Dear Team BIRDS
Many thanks again for entering your idea into the Fly Your Ideas competition and although you were not successful in progressing to Round 2 we hope you are still supporting the other teams currently taking part.
As promised please see below the feedback on your Round 1 submission from the team of Assessors who reviewed your proposal.
• The title of your proposal clearly and accurately described your idea;
• Your proposal accurately described the state of the art for the area your project focuses on;
• Your idea and its features are well conceived and clearly described;
• The idea itself is interesting and innovative – in comparison to current practice;
• You have identified the principle challenge and barriers for implementation of your idea;
• The potential benefits linked to your idea are clearly explained;
• Your proposal did not clearly identify the economic benefits you expect your idea to deliver;
• Overall you have shown a well defined plan to progress the development of your idea;
• Your overall approach to quantitative measurements of your idea needed development.
Notes/ Areas to consider:
• How could temp. Gradient be maintained, without power? Enough Suction?
Thank you for taking part in the Airbus Fly Your Ideas 2013 competition. We wish you well with your ongoing studies and your future career.
Kind regards,
Airbus Fly Your Ideas Team"
The feedback doesn't provide much detail as to why our proposal was not chosen to go further in the competition.
Although we are disappointed that we are not able to proceed in the competition, we will use the feedback and notes that the Airbus panel have given us to improve on our idea for the University MEng group project.
"Dear Team BIRDS
Many thanks again for entering your idea into the Fly Your Ideas competition and although you were not successful in progressing to Round 2 we hope you are still supporting the other teams currently taking part.
As promised please see below the feedback on your Round 1 submission from the team of Assessors who reviewed your proposal.
• The title of your proposal clearly and accurately described your idea;
• Your proposal accurately described the state of the art for the area your project focuses on;
• Your idea and its features are well conceived and clearly described;
• The idea itself is interesting and innovative – in comparison to current practice;
• You have identified the principle challenge and barriers for implementation of your idea;
• The potential benefits linked to your idea are clearly explained;
• Your proposal did not clearly identify the economic benefits you expect your idea to deliver;
• Overall you have shown a well defined plan to progress the development of your idea;
• Your overall approach to quantitative measurements of your idea needed development.
Notes/ Areas to consider:
• How could temp. Gradient be maintained, without power? Enough Suction?
Thank you for taking part in the Airbus Fly Your Ideas 2013 competition. We wish you well with your ongoing studies and your future career.
Kind regards,
Airbus Fly Your Ideas Team"
The feedback doesn't provide much detail as to why our proposal was not chosen to go further in the competition.
Although we are disappointed that we are not able to proceed in the competition, we will use the feedback and notes that the Airbus panel have given us to improve on our idea for the University MEng group project.